How To Make Better Product Decisions Shreyas Doshi

Click to expand the mind map for a detailed view.

Key Takeaways

  • Focusing Illusion: Avoid overemphasizing the importance of a single issue or feature by recognizing the “focusing illusion” — nothing is as important as it seems while you’re thinking about it.
  • Customer Problem Stack Rank (CPSR): Use stack ranking to prioritize customer problems, ensuring you focus on their top concerns rather than lower-priority requests.
  • Ongoing Stack Rank (OSR): Implement an ongoing stack rank for internal projects to prevent overcommitment and ensure alignment with top priorities.
  • Contextual Decision-Making: Evaluate the importance of any new request or feature in the context of all ongoing work, minimizing opportunity costs.
  • Rigorous Prioritization: Avoid building features or products that address low-priority problems, as they are unlikely to gain traction even if executed well.

Detailed Summary

Focusing Illusion

  • Definition: The tendency to overestimate the importance of a problem or feature while discussing it, leading to skewed priorities.
    • Actionable Insight: Recognize that customers and teams often overemphasize the importance of a single issue due to the focusing illusion.
    • Actionable Insight: Avoid making decisions in isolation; always consider the broader context of other priorities.
    • Actionable Insight: Use tools like stack ranking to counteract the focusing illusion and ensure balanced decision-making.

Customer Problem Stack Rank (CPSR)

  • Purpose: To identify and prioritize the most critical problems faced by customers.
    • Actionable Insight: Ask customers to describe all their current problems and then stack rank them by importance.
    • Actionable Insight: Focus on solving the top 1-3 problems, as these are the ones customers are most likely to act on.
    • Actionable Insight: Avoid building features for low-priority problems, as they are unlikely to be used even if implemented.

Ongoing Stack Rank (OSR)

  • Purpose: To maintain clarity and alignment on internal project priorities.
    • Actionable Insight: Create a stack rank of all ongoing projects, clearly identifying the most and least important ones.
    • Actionable Insight: Use the stack rank to evaluate new requests, ensuring they are prioritized appropriately relative to existing work.
    • Actionable Insight: Prevent overcommitment by using the stack rank to say “no” or “not now” to lower-priority requests.

Contextual Decision-Making

  • Importance: Decisions should be made in the context of all ongoing work, not in isolation.
    • Actionable Insight: Evaluate the opportunity cost of any new request or feature by comparing it to existing priorities.
    • Actionable Insight: Avoid binary thinking (important vs. not important) and instead assess relative importance.
    • Actionable Insight: Use stack ranking to ensure decisions align with the company’s top strategic goals.

Rigorous Prioritization

  • Avoid Low-Priority Work: Building features or products for low-priority problems is unlikely to succeed.
    • Actionable Insight: Validate the importance of a problem through stack ranking before committing resources to solve it.
    • Actionable Insight: Focus on problems that are in the top 3-5 priorities for a significant number of customers.
    • Actionable Insight: Recognize that even well-executed solutions to low-priority problems will struggle to gain traction.

Conversational Insights

  1. “Nothing in life is as important as you think it is while you are thinking about it.”
  2. “The focusing illusion leads us to overemphasize the importance of a single issue, often at the expense of broader priorities.”
  3. “Customers may say a feature is important, but without stack ranking, it’s hard to know if it’s truly a top priority.”
  4. “Stack ranking forces you to evaluate the importance of a problem in the context of everything else, minimizing opportunity costs.”
  5. “Most businesses barely get a chance to work on their first or second priority in any given quarter, so focus on the top 1-3 problems.”
  6. “Without stack ranking, new requests are often discussed in isolation, leading to overcommitment and misaligned priorities.”
  7. “The real question isn’t whether something is important, but how important it is relative to everything else.”
  8. “Building a beautiful product for a low-priority problem is a recipe for failure, no matter how well you execute.”
  9. “Stack ranking is a simple but profoundly powerful tool for making better and more rigorous product decisions.”
  10. “Avoid binary thinking — evaluate the importance of any new request in the context of all ongoing work.”